All Posts

The Dark Side of UX: Ethical Considerations in Design

Dark patterns, data privacy, and manipulative design—where do we draw the line?

In this article

What Are Dark Patterns?The Hero’s Journey for BrandsEmotional Connection vs. Selling a ProductThe Role of Copywriting in Brand StorytellingCase Studies: Brands with Powerful NarrativesHow to Craft Your Brand’s StoryFinal ThoughtsWhat's Next?

What Are Dark Patterns?

Dark patterns are deceptive UX strategies designed to manipulate users into taking actions they might not otherwise choose. These tactics prioritize business goals over user well-being, leading to frustration, distrust, and even regulatory backlash.

Common examples of dark patterns include:

  • Forced continuity – Free trials that automatically convert into paid subscriptions without clear notice.
  • Hidden fees – Unexpected charges that appear only at checkout.
  • Roach motel – Easy to sign up, but difficult to cancel.
  • Confirmshaming – Guilt-tripping users into opting into something (e.g., "No thanks, I don’t care about saving money").

Dark patterns exploit human psychology, making it difficult for users to make informed decisions. While they may drive short-term gains, they ultimately damage brand reputation and customer trust.

The Hero’s Journey for Brands

Not all persuasive design is unethical. Ethical UX guides users toward beneficial actions without misleading them, while dark patterns trick users into decisions they might regret.

The difference between ethical persuasion and dark patterns:

For example, Duolingo’s reminders are persuasive but not deceptive, using friendly nudges instead of aggressive tactics. In contrast, some fitness apps use panic-inducing notifications to pressure users into subscriptions.

Designers must balance business objectives with ethical responsibility, ensuring UX fosters trust, not manipulation.

Emotional Connection vs. Selling a Product

Data privacy is becoming a major concern, with users demanding more control over their personal information. Ethical UX must prioritize transparency and consent over hidden data collection practices.

Privacy-first UX principles:

  • Clear data policies – Users should understand what data is collected and why.
  • Opt-in, not opt-out – Users should actively consent to data collection rather than being automatically enrolled.
  • Easy data management – Users should be able to delete or modify their data without hassle.

Apple has taken a strong stance on privacy, introducing App Tracking Transparency, which allows users to opt out of third-party tracking easily. In contrast, many social media platforms have faced backlash for complex and hidden privacy settings.

A privacy-first approach isn’t just good ethics—it’s a competitive advantage in a world where trust is becoming a premium.

The Role of Copywriting in Brand Storytelling

Trustworthy UX design fosters long-term relationships with users, making them feel safe, respected, and valued.

Best practices for designing with trust:

✔ Honest messaging – Avoid misleading labels and deceptive language.
✔ Transparent pricing – Display all costs upfront to prevent last-minute surprises.
✔ Easy opt-outs – Allow users to unsubscribe or cancel without excessive friction.
✔ Secure design – Use HTTPS, security badges, and clear privacy policies.

Example: Basecamp’s cancellation process is straightforward, with no hidden fees or tricks, reinforcing trust. In contrast, some streaming services make canceling intentionally difficult, leading to user frustration.

A brand that prioritizes honesty over manipulation earns customer loyalty and positive word-of-mouth.

Case Studies: Brands with Powerful Narratives

Who’s Doing It Right?

✅ Mozilla Firefox – Focuses on privacy-first UX, providing clear data controls.
✅ Patagonia – Uses transparent pricing and ethical messaging in branding.
✅ Figma – Encourages collaboration without forcing users into paid plans.

Who’s Doing It Wrong?

🚫 Facebook (now Meta) – Repeated privacy scandals and misleading data policies.
🚫 Ticketmaster – Hidden fees and last-minute pricing manipulations.
🚫 LinkedIn – Uses dark patterns in email notifications to drive re-engagement.

Users are increasingly aware of manipulative UX tactics, and brands that fail to prioritize ethical design risk losing trust and credibility.

How to Craft Your Brand’s Story

The demand for ethical, user-first design is growing, driven by new regulations, user expectations, and industry accountability.

What’s next for ethical UX?

✔ Stronger data protection laws – GDPR and CCPA are just the beginning.
✔ Greater user autonomy – More companies adopting transparent opt-in policies.
✔ AI-driven ethics checks – AI tools analyzing UX designs for ethical violations.

Regulators and users alike are pushing back against manipulative design, and the brands that adapt will be the ones that thrive.

Final Thoughts

Dark patterns and unethical UX practices may drive short-term engagement, but they ultimately erode trust and damage brand reputation.

Key Takeaways:

  • Dark patterns manipulate users and reduce long-term trust.
  • Ethical UX balances persuasion with honesty.
  • Privacy-first design builds credibility and user confidence.
  • Trustworthy brands prioritize transparency and user control.

The future of UX isn’t about tricking users—it’s about respecting them.

What's Next?

Is your UX designed to help users or manipulate them? It’s time to rethink ethical design in the digital age.

Written by
Nathan James
February 24, 2025
WORK WITH RESOLUTE

Want to talk? Coffee on us!

By submitting, you give Resolute permission to store and process your personal information so we can provide you with the content you’ve requested. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.